Wednesday, July 20, 2011

A pilot on the TSA's inappropriate behavior



H/T Boycott Flying

An assessment I agree with

The Atlantic has an editorial amid the recent pushes by Rep Chaffetz that the TSA implement more use of dogs. The truth of its final paragraphs can't be denied:
...  Most Americans ... understand that reinforced cockpit doors and the determination of airline passengers to fight back against hijackers are the most important security innovations to occur since 9/11.

In my estimation, TSA's failure to encourage assertiveness among the traveling public is its biggest failure of omission. Passengers, not screening personnel, stopped the shoe bomber and that guy who lit his underwear on fire. But air travelers are never explicitly told to fight if necessary. Nor are volunteers trained to function as something between a neighborhood watch program and a mile high national guard. We rely on surprisingly costly air marshals when with a little effort, a percentage of the traveling public might be persuaded to undergo training. Certainly they would've done so if asked by the president shortly after the September 11 attacks. Instead we've created a clunky bureaucracy that has mostly succeeded in making a subset of the traveling public feel embarrassed, violated, harassed, or otherwise upset. On the other hand, they've got 500 cute puppies.

'Wasteful spending' at ports

Is there any other kind when the TSA and Congress are involved?
To protect our ports, the federal government committed $420 million to work badges.
...But even though many workers have [biometric ID] cards, WFTV found secure entrances at Port Canaveral that had no equipment to scan their thumbprint.

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Update on Yukari Miyamae

She will not be charged with a felony, although a misdemeanor is still possible. In fact, the judge released her without bail due to a lack of probable cause.

Federal anti-groping, anti-scanning bill

From a statesman, not a politician (Chaffetz and Mica, anyone?):

Rep. Ron Paul, R-Texas, on Thursday introduced legislation that would ensure that "any federal employee or agency or any individual or entity that receives federal funds are not immune from any US law regarding physical contact with another person, making images of another person, or causing physical harm through the use of radiation-emitting machinery on another person."
...
"What we ultimately need is real privatization of security, but not phony privatization with the same TSA screeners in private security firm uniforms still operating under the 'guidance' of the federal government," Paul said in a statement introducing the bill. "Real security will be achieved when the airlines are once again in charge of protecting their property and their passengers."

Invasions of personal space

Everyone has their own line. Mine was getting viewed naked or touched intimately against my will. This woman was willing to put up with the naked scan and even a body pat-down, but felt the unsolicited hair tousling was too far. And I have no doubt that she's right that the TSA policies are applied inconsistently, so, whether this is racially motivated or not, her story of other women with big hair getting a pass is entirely believable.

This line in the article gives me the creeps, though:
While the TSA website states 'head coverings' are subject to search, there is no mention of how travellers should wear hair.
Really? If the TSA did have instructions for how travelers should wear their hair, would that be better or worse? I'm going with the latter.

Will history repeat itself?

On the demise of the puffer, and an illustration of government waste (at all levels of the government).

The Transportation Security Administration began using puffer machines in 2004 inside airports, but it started getting rid of them by 2008.

TSA spent about $29.6 million on its more than 200 machines and $6.2 million on their maintenance, said Sarah R. Horowitz, a TSA spokeswoman.

Horowitz wrote in an email to The Ledger that the machines were prone to frequent maintenance issues.

"Additionally, they were found to be more expensive to maintain than projected," Horowitz wrote. "Maintenance issues occurred because the dirt and humidity that naturally occurs in airport environments hindered the operation of this equipment."

D'ya think we're right to be worried whether the naked scanners will continue to operate properly?

Monday, July 18, 2011

What's legal for the TSA is illegal for anyone else

We still don't really know what happened at the Phoenix airport that led to the arrest of a 61-year-old frequent-flier. The TSA agent, who was trying to grab Yukari Mihamae's Miyamae's breasts under cover of the law, claims that Mihamae Miyamae grabbed her breasts (back?). But Mihamae Miyamae is denying this.

Does it really matter? The point is clear: A TSA agent can do whatever it wants and the TSA as well as local authorities will stand behind the agent. If a passenger protests too much, said passenger will be arrested.

Here's the "choice" we get when we pay an airline hundreds of dollars to travel within our own country:
  • Be viewed naked, getting exposed to additional unnecessary radiation (which have not definitively been shown to be harmless, by the way)
  • Get aggressively searched, including touching of the genitals and breasts and possibly including inordinate humiliation, particularly if you have a medical condition
  • Get arrested

EPIV v DHS decision

In short, the court says the scanners aren't unconstitutional because violating privacy is necessary, but, since they do indeed violate privacy, the TSA should have had a public comment period before installing them. The judge must have been channeling Orwell.

At least that's my take on it. Here are a few others:
UPDATE: For what it's worth, I just want to say that - while I applaud the efforts of EPIC - I do not see any possibility of legal success through the courts on this matter. EPIC has done an excellent job of bringing focus to this issue, but in the end it is the government ruling about whether the government is doing a good job. Once in awhile there's a victory here, but mostly these cases just show what a sham the system is. Sorry to be such a downer. I guess what I'm trying to say is that if you want to expend your energy on something, you have to be realistic about the likely outcomes. To that end, I don't think an airline boycott is likely to help abolish the TSA. See my earlier post on this.

    Scanned then molested. But, why?

    This frequent-flier was reduced to tears and wants to know why:

    A mainstream journalist comes around

    Despite his nationalistic views on war and terrorism, the image of a 7-year-old assuming the position in a body scanner woke up a journalist who wrote at the NBC website:
    In Baghdad, I had to go through an earlier model of the machine before I was allowed to enter a courtroom for the trial of Saddam Hussein. That seemed reasonable at the time. There were millions of Iraqis who wanted to kill Saddam, or to at least disrupt his trial. The blurred-naked-photo-machine didn’t bother me then.
    It did bother me as I stood with my feet in outlines on the floor and my hands over my head, palms pressed together in Los Angeles. It bothered me even more as I watched a girl who couldn’t have been more than 7 years old forced to assume the same undignified position. I watched her mother help the girl, showing her how to raise her hands in the correct position. 

    Expectant mothers' concerns

    I cam across this interesting thread on a forum for hopeful mothers. The consensus is that these women don't trust the scanners one bit, and good for them!

    Here's the deal, ladies. There is basically zero science on what the effects of the naked scanners (be it ionizing or non-ionizing radiation) are on a developing fetus. Hopefully there is no danger and our government didn't just poison the next generation. But why risk it?

    Also, remember that you are going to be more sensitive during your pregnancy - both physically and emotionally. Carefully consider how you might react when a stranger violently gropes you, asks you to expose your belly, or questions what those pads are in your bra or what that elastic band is around your waist before you buy your plane tickets.

    WaPo editorial lambasts 'belly bombs' warning

    Good for Alexandra Petri, a Washington Post blogger, who writes of the belly bomb threat:
    ...this has moved beyond the realm of parody into whatever realm is beyond parody, maybe Narnia. Clearly nothing is too absurd to be considered a threat by the TSA.